What was that skit in The Secret Policeman's Ball? After the umpteenth time the Apocalypse *doesn't* happen, the cult leader sends the members on their way with a cheery, "Well, we're bound to hit it right *some* day!"
That's quite funny. Colleagues were discussing a similar take on this at work today. One day the cultists might get it right and be able to declare they were right after all. Except, they won't be around to declare victory.
My bet though is on 6 hours after local solar noon.
That was my other ponderance, whether YHWH would abide by our arbitrary mortal timekeeping standards and "beam up" entire time zones at once (what is the capactiy of the pattern buffer on His supplicant transporter, anyway?) or go by true meridian lines.
Quote:
But what I haven't figured out yet is what will happen to true believers that are on an airplane leaving Hawaii Saturday for Asia. That could leave some of them behind with the skeptics
I had exactly the same thought yesterday, perhaps subconsciously prompted by Carlin's bit about kids trying to stump the priest by surrounding a fairly straightforward sin with the most outrageous circumstances.
"Earth diameter is 7,900 miles, and Moon diameter is 2,160 miles. It takes on average 90 minutes to complete one Earth orbit, so one Moon orbit should take roughly 25 minutes." - Sam "NasaScam" Colby
"you data is still open for interpretation, after all a NASA employee might of wipe a booger or dropped a hair on it" - showtime
Raptureready.com agrees with you and has all sorts of biblical reasoning to say why Brother Camping is wrong.
But that's just it... they quote several Biblical passages essentially saying that Camping can't know, but they can't claim that he is wrong.
From that site: Quote:
It hasn't happened yet and it will probably not happen on May 21...
...and when this date does come and go - when nothing biblically relevant happens...
Emphasis mine.
These statements smack of hypocracy. The author, Chris Mangan, claims to believe that the Rapture will happen, and that no mortal can know when it will happen... which, by definition, means no mortal can known when it won't happen, either. Mangan has no basis on which to calculate the probability of an event which has never occurred in human history, of which no human has control, and of which there will (apparently) be no advance warning. By declaring that the date in question will come and go uneventfully, he has ruled out not only that date, but every date between then and whenever this piece was authored.
Any believer who flatly sates that the rapture won't happen today unwittingly betrays their lack of faith that it will ever happen.
"Earth diameter is 7,900 miles, and Moon diameter is 2,160 miles. It takes on average 90 minutes to complete one Earth orbit, so one Moon orbit should take roughly 25 minutes." - Sam "NasaScam" Colby
"you data is still open for interpretation, after all a NASA employee might of wipe a booger or dropped a hair on it" - showtime
Raptureready.com agrees with you and has all sorts of biblical reasoning to say why Brother Camping is wrong.
But that's just it... they quote several Biblical passages essentially saying that Camping can't know, but they can't claim that he is wrong.
From that site: Quote:
It hasn't happened yet and it will probably not happen on May 21...
...and when this date does come and go - when nothing biblically relevant happens...
Emphasis mine.
These statements smack of hypocracy. The author, Chris Mangan, claims to believe that the Rapture will happen, and that no mortal can know when it will happen... which, by definition, means no mortal can known when it won't happen, either. Mangan has no basis on which to calculate the probability of an event which has never occurred in human history, of which no human has control, and of which there will (apparently) be no advance warning. By declaring that the date in question will come and go uneventfully, he has ruled out not only that date, but every date between then and whenever this piece was authored.
Any believer who flatly sates that the rapture won't happen today unwittingly betrays their lack of faith that it will ever happen.
I viewed it as a healthy scientific skepticism. You know, realizing that knowledge is probabilistic and held provisional. Not to be held with pure certainty.
Joined: May 2005 Gender: Male Posts: 3,122 Location: Space City, Texas
Re: It's the end of the world as we know it... aga « Reply #21 on May 21, 2011, 6:08am »
Actually I am thinking about collecting some old clothes and arranging sets of them in public places to look like the former occupant was taken. We'll see how much spare time I have today.
Joined: Dec 2005 Gender: Male Posts: 261 Location: Nederland - Sol III
Re: It's the end of the world as we know it... aga « Reply #24 on May 21, 2011, 12:36pm »
I'm still here. It's 18:35 and there is no chaos outside.
Maybe the rapture happened in September 1994 as per Camping's previous prediction. If only a few thousand people disappeared world-wide, it might have gone by without people realising it.
I'm still here. It's 18:35 and there is no chaos outside.
Maybe the rapture happened in September 1994 as per Camping's previous prediction. If only a few thousand people disappeared world-wide, it might have gone by without people realising it.
It would say things about Camping, though, wouldn't it?
And I don't think denying this day as the day of the Rapture is the same as denying belief in the Rapture. Certainly it's possible that it could have happened between the time the piece was written and the time the Rapture was claimed for, but I really do think the answer lies in the false prophets referenced in the Bible. By definition, claiming to know something that Jesus said no one knows would make you a false prophet in Christianity, and it would therefore be a true believer's duty to disbelieve you.